Consumer Duty: FCA New Consultation Commandment

Written on
byJames Gallagher

The Golden Rule. It’s taught on our first day of school – treat others as you would like to be treated. This fundamental and central principle to living in society is the driving force behind the FCA’s Consumer Duty consultation paper. Sparked by the FCA’s 2020 Financial Lives Survey which highlights that only 35% of respondents believe that FS firms are honest and transparent. The FCA is not calling FS firms barbarians but heralds that their duty to customers should be taken to a higher level of expectation.


In their opening lines, the FCA calls forth this higher expectation. “We want to see a higher level of consumer protection in retail financial markets, where firms are competing vigorously in the interests of consumers… For many firms, this would require a significant shift in culture and behaviour”. This quotation should be broken into two parts. First, vigorous competition means firms should be placing customer service as a top priority in competition differentiation. Secondly, a significant shift will require a renewal of FS firms culture – that even if already benevolent – has to be taken to a higher level of care.


The FCA has brought to the fore what it calls “sludge” practises – deeds firms take to intentionally slow down customers from taking actions the firm does not want them to – like leaving for a competitor. They differentiate this to friction processes such as “cooling off” periods or fraudulent checking that while slow can be in the best interest of all parties. While there are some malevolent firms that do intend to manipulate customers, there are many who are only guilty of being lackluster in their full customer lifecycle service. Of course a firm will focus and pay particular attention to customer service when onboarding a customer, that is how they get sales after all. What the FCA wants is better concentration and action on the full customer lifecycle service and experience. 


Many of you will be familiar with the government’s so-called “Nudge” department (or, as they are officially known – the Behavioural Insights Team). They use the techniques covered in the Nobel prize winning economists book, by the same name, on how to incentivize individuals by small changes such as framing of information. To make the example personal I shall share an experience I had recently that shows what companies may do. 


We all get thousands of emails a day – even when we click the no marketing information checkbox! From one specific company I had 6 emails in a month, which although is not tremendous, when we consider the amount of products and services we consume – it soon adds up. Furthermore, many of these emails do not need to be read – woe to the amount of emails I receive giving me my monthly bill in the age of subscription price modeling. The situation itself is a common one, my 18 month contract bill was now going to increase. Again, nothing unusual or unethical, it’s a very normal contract. The subject heading I received in my email read “A little reminder about your contract”. Now yes this is objectively true, one part of my contract was about to change. I was going to pay more for the same service. But how innocent does the phrase sound compared to “Remember your contract is changing”. All of a sudden this now seems something more demanding that needs action. Or, finally what if it was just plain and simple “Your bill is increasing”.


You see from the example above the firm did not really do anything wrong, particularly from a legal standpoint. But they were also not clear with me, which led me to pay double what I could have paid at any other provider for 3 months before I even noticed. The worst part is I was an economics and finance student! I understand nudge theory and how to properly manage money, but even I fell victim – so what chance does a vulnerable customer have?


In all our relationships whether with friends or FS firms we want clear communication that does not intentionally omit important context. The Consumer Duty Consultation Paper speaks to 4 different areas of what businesses need to treat customers fairly.


Communications: Originally Principal 7 which deals with communication thought that the provision of information would cause consumers to consider it all thoroughly. However, they now know many are constrained in comprehension and so the focus changes to what is the outcome for the customer. If a firm is aware that an individual may have a better option they must make it clear without overloading and misleading customers.


Products & Services: These products are tailored for the best outcome for the consumer. This must be done in: needs; products should be designed for usage (like the phone contract with a million minutes of calls that would never be used), biases; take into consideration trends in irrational behaviour (taking on more credit than one can pay back), actions; allow customers to easily act (allowing customers to change contracts or providers).


Customer Service: Firms should provide customer service that meets the needs of the consumer in a way that is focused on the outcomes of the consumer. If the consumer needs help to understand, make changes or move to another service then this should be aided.


Price & Value: Prices should be set on the value that the service and/or products give to the outcome of the individual. Although the FCA will not necessarily be price makers, they should overview that comprehensive and reasonable pricing methodologies were and continue to be utilised by the firm.


We here at Aveni take our consumer duty seriously. We offer a bespoke solution to using AI when it comes to customer service call monitoring and speech analytics. Naturally the solution of each firm and its products are different which requires specialised solutions yet many in the industry use off the shelf methods that simply do not meet the needs of our clients’ customers.


If you want to provide a quality service to your customers then you need to be able to listen to them. Using NLP and AI technology to highlight the needs and vulnerabilities of 100% of customer contact will let you know what you need to do. Remember it is about understanding the outcomes for your customers and the only way you can know what is best for your customer is by listening to them yourself.


Want to learn more about how our market-leading AI and speech technology can help you fulfil your consumer duty requirements?  Click here 

Learn more about what we do. Visit Aveni Detect

Other recent posts

CRO Consumer Duty survey findings: Customers at the heart of your business? Now is the time to prove it.

CRO Consumer Duty survey findings: Customers at the heart of your business? Now is the time to prove it.

We surveyed +80 Senior Compliance and Risk Officers from across the UK’s Financial Services sector to find out their top priorities and investment plans for Consumer Duty and how they’ll meet the tightening data-driven...

Aveni’s end of the year Reunion!

Aveni's end of the year Reunion!

Aveni works at the forefront of innovation in AI and Natural Language Processing, providing quality assurance and regulatory compliance solutions for financial services and utilities companies in the UK. However, that’s not all we...

Adoption of machine learning and data driven technologies at the heart of human centred advice

Adoption of machine learning and data driven technologies at the heart of human centred advice

This is an excerpt from our Human+ whitepaper. Download here for full details about how data driven technologies can power human centred advice.   The recent acceleration in digitisation of financial advice combined with advances...

executive understanding ai

AI: Why an executive understanding is so important’  - 5 key takeaways from Aveni Labs webinar

Data-driven technologies underpinned by rapidly evolving AI, are set to be placed at the heart of firms’ operating models. It emphasises the need for Financial Services Executives to have a clear understanding of AI,...

Record calls consumer duty

The FCA emphasises the importance of recording customer calls to meet Consumer Duty requirements

In the FCA’s recent Consumer Duty Retail Lending webinar, Jonathan Phelan, Head of Department, Consumer Finance at the FCA urged firms to record customer interactions as a critical step in being able to monitor...

financial advice data capturing

Driving Automation in the Financial Advice Industry with Data Capturing

The present day financial advice industry has seen little innovation since the turn of the last decade, but is now entering a period where it will be fundamentally disrupted.    The industry has relied...

Colin Clark Aveni Chairman

Investment heavyweight Colin Clark appointed as chair of AI fintech business Aveni has appointed investment heavyweight Colin Clark as Chairman of its newly formed Board. The strategic appointment comes in the wake of a recent successful funding injection of £2.75 million to grow market share...

financial services space

Aveni's busy week: FinTech Award Win, HomeGame 2 and JP Morgan Innovation Events!

Last week was a busy one for Aveni. From winning a Scottish Financial Technology award to being a part of two exciting and impactful events with JP Morgan and the langcat, we loved getting...

Impact of AI

Human+: Human-in-the-Loop AI

AI is already changing our lives; from expert systems which predict the weather and the stock market, to facial recognition and internet search results. Its application is growing more extensive. Some uses of AI...